Effective Document Management Strategies for Microsoft 365 - SharePoint edition

Managing documents effectively in Microsoft 365 SharePoint is a common challenge for organizations. To address challenges that arise, organizations must implement a structured approach to document management that evolves based on their needs. Join as we explore different levels of document management maturity, from default document libraries to advanced extensibility solutions.

Document Management Problem Statement

Common document management issues include difficulties in locating files, poor search functionality, duplicate documents with different names, and permission mismanagement. A particularly frustrating issue is the accidental reorganization of files - such as unintentionally moving a folder - leading to confusion and lost productivity. Addressing these challenges requires a thoughtful strategy for structuring and managing documents in SharePoint.

SharePoint Scenarios

Organizations typically follow an evolutionary path in document management, starting with the default document library, moving to custom libraries, and ultimately leveraging multiple sites for better organization. Understanding these levels helps organizations determine which structure best suits their needs.

Default Documents Library

At its most basic level, SharePoint provides a single, default document library for each site. This setup can work for small teams with minimal content but quickly becomes inefficient as organizations scale. While the default library offers a central location with basic features like folders, metadata, versioning, and simple views, it has limitations. Long URLs, duplicate files, and security concerns make it difficult to manage large volumes of documents effectively. Additionally, content retention becomes a challenge when different types of documents with varying retention requirements are stored in the same library. Recognizing when this approach is no longer sufficient is crucial to avoiding long-term inefficiencies.

Custom Libraries

Moving beyond the default library, organizations can implement custom document libraries, representing a level 200 on the maturity model. Custom libraries allow for better organization by categorizing documents based on content type and metadata rather than relying solely on folders. For example, an organization might create a dedicated policy library with specific metadata for policies. This structure enhances searchability and information architecture. However, transitioning to custom libraries requires training employees on proper document placement, which can be a hurdle for adoption.

Multiple Sites

At a more advanced stage (maturity level 300/400), organizations leverage multiple SharePoint sites to manage different units of work. Permissions are easier to manage at the site level, providing a streamlined approach to controlling access. Additionally, this method simplifies external user collaboration, as guests can be restricted to specific sites. However, some IT teams express concerns over site sprawl. The key is to balance the number of sites with the organization’s operational needs while implementing lifecycle and retention management policies to prevent clutter. Synchronization of multiple sites to local machines can also be challenging, requiring a structured approach to avoid overwhelming users with excessive folders.

Extensibility Solutions to Overcome Limitations

For organizations operating at a 500-level maturity model, extensibility solutions can address out-of-the-box SharePoint limitations. For example, managing invoices across multiple project sites can be cumbersome. A potential solution is to create a drop library for accounting vendor invoices, tagging them with project details and using automation to surface relevant documents to accounting teams. Additionally, modern solutions like PnP modern search and AI-powered SharePoint agents help enhance search capabilities and document organization. These advanced tools can significantly improve document management efficiency.

Organizations must assess their document management needs and maturity level to implement the most suitable approach. By leveraging metadata, structured libraries, and automation, businesses can enhance searchability, streamline permissions, and improve overall document governance. The key is continuous adaptation to ensure that document management solutions scale with organizational growth and requirements!

All Resources

• Maturity Model for Microsoft 365 - Management of Content Competency
• SharePoint Online Limits - Items in lists and libraries
• ShareGate
• Orchestry

Do you have any questions for us? Continue the conversation on BlueSky with the hashtag #AskSympraxis and mention @sympraxisconsulting.com.